China in the china shop

China, iron-ore, and Australia.

Corruption in China. A controversial topic: a reality that should be acknowledged and discussed in the open, regardless of what damage it might do to China’s sensitive face.

The arrest of Rio Tinto’s man in China, Mr Stern Hu, for allegedly offering a bribe gives us pause for reflection on this topic.

If this highly respected Australian-Chinese negotiator was dealing under the table, then he was following normal Chinese procedure. His contacts in government and in private industry (they are one and the same anyway) would have expected such behaviour from him. Failure to operate according to these local business rules would have put him and his employer at a commercial disadvantage.

Regardless of which party to the negotiations offered a bribe or requested a fee for an illegal service, the fact remains that this kind of behaviour is par for the course in China.

In fact, the government of China is a routine breaker of its own laws in this regard. Ask the local people: for example; the Long Chuan county office near Chengdu in Sichuan Province is known to them as “Corruption Castle”. A government office closer to my home in Chongqing is blessed with a similar moniker.

These “corruption castles” are everywhere. They are a part of China’s glorious 2000-year-old tradition (since the first emperor, Qin Shi Huang Di) of allowing government officers to milk their local populations for personal benefit. It is a culturally accepted practice. As it is in much of Asia.

Don’t be fooled by the occasional example of a high-flying official being punished for having his fingers in the till. These arrests are rarely the result of any general campaign against the evils of corruption. Rather, they are the result of political intrigue, and are an accepted means of getting rid of one’s enemies. For example; this is how Hu Jin Tau got rid of a troublesome mayor of Shanghai a couple of years ago.

So China should not add insult to injury by playing the corruption card or threatening the world with punishment for the sale of so-called “state secrets”. This spurious tactic won’t work.

Better to spare us the hypocrisy, and tell us the real reason for this crude attempt at intimidation. A tactic which has the potential to do lasting damage to China’s global commercial reputation.

China is not a democracy; it is a dictatorship. China is not a market economy; it is a centrally controlled economy. Thus, when the pressure is on, China reverts to type. It bullies.

Things haven’t been going China’s way lately. Internally as well as externally. So the barbarians within China’s borders are behaving as barbarians do: they are throwing their weight around in order to get what they want.