Herbert Hoover, the Republican |
Franklin D. Roosevelt, the Democrat |
Childhood: "Hoover was born in pinch poverty in the little town of West Branch, Iowa, where every home is humble." |
Childhood: Roosevelt was America's little Lord Fauntleroy, the child of a Hudson River squire. He grew up in Hyde Park, NY. |
Hobbies: "Hoover [the poor country pupil] entertained himself with sticks and tacks, strings, wires and nails and the assortment of things the village smithy leaves scattered in the shade of the chestnut tree." |
Hobbies: "Franklin played with imported toys under the tutelage and protection of a governess [to the age of fourteen!], which ever is the nicest term." Then, he was off to Groton, the elite preparatory school. |
Education: Hoover, the orphan, worked his way though Stanford, because he was not too proud to do laundry work. |
Education: Franklin Roosevelt's daddy dear, paid his son's way into Harvard, living "on the Gold Coast" and then Columbia. |
Even so, Democrats attacked Hoover's wealth. Sure FDR was richer, yet, to be sure, the chattering classes didn't want Iowa's orphan to climb. They even blamed the job-producing pioneer for inheriting the Great Depression.
Nonetheless, some newspaper owners couldn't stomach FDR but in Modern Times (The World from the Twenties to the Nineties) Paul Johnson (page 257) explains that:
Advertisement
... their journalists loved him, forgiving him his frequent lies, concealing the fact that he took money off them from poker (which had damned Harding), obeying his malicious injunctions to give his Administration colleagues “a hard time”.
There were dark corners in the Roosevelt White House: his own infidelities, his wife's passionate attachments to another woman, the unscrupulous, sometimes vicious manner in which he used executive power. None was exposed in his lifetime or for long after.
Of course, society's snobs were clearly jealous of Hoover's relationship too. But why? Because he was happily married whereas FDR was living in some freaky arrangement; because Mrs Hoover opened the doors of hospitality to the wives of black congressmen in the pre-Civil Rights era; because Hoover married in a Catholic ceremony (well before JFK became a "groundbreaker"). Oh, and because good Protestant men trouble godless Democrats. And that's the raw truth. Iowa's favourite orphan was too Christian for them all.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
4 posts so far.
About the Author
Ben-Peter Terpstra has provided commentary for The Daily Caller (Washington D.C.), NewsReal Blog (Los Angeles), Quadrant (Sydney), and Menzies House (Adelaide).