"Yes" colleague Teela Reid also believes the Voice is about forcing "reparations" upon white people and "redistributing power".
"First Nations want the power in their hands, that's what the Voice is about…a journey with all Australians to begin to demolish the systems that continue to oppress us."
Linda Burney says The Voice won't attempt to change Australia Day. Ms Reid says it will abolish it if it wants to.
Advertisement
I guess we can't have Austratians celebrating "Invasion Day" even though the British "invaders" have a much better record at advancing their colony here and in other places around the globe than some of their European counterparts. Undoubtedly some bad things happened in the past, there were frontier conflicts, but there was never an official mainland "war" against so-called "first nations" people. That label borrowed from Canada/ US is a misnomer as there is evidence of an earlier race or races displaced by aborigines. According to some experts, they share DNA with tribes in India, who migrated much more recently than the accepted ancient timeline.
It's also sad that The Voice Debate has heaped vitriol on two leading "No" campaigners, prominent indigenous figures Warren Mundine and The Opposition's Shadow Indigenous Affairs Minister, Senator Jacinta Price. Mundine in particular has revealed in interviews on Sky News that he twice seriously considered suicide because of unrelenting abuse from some of his own people and vocal "Yes" advocates. He is now reportedly seeking professional help, but says he is also worried about Senator Price over similar treatment she and members of her close family have been subjected to.
That's terrible and I'm sure I stand with many fair-minded Aussies on both sides of the debate in wishing them both well.
But in recent days faced with the declining polls, the tone of the Yes campaign has mellowed somewhat and it seems to be now more focussed on trusting "the vibe" than labelling anyone who disagrees as racist.
The last Parliamentary sittings did nothing to enhance the Yes case, with the PM, Miss Burney and other Labor luminaries dodging direct questions on The Voice, including the Makaratta Commission's direct link with Treaty and Truth. The usual obfuscation, sniggers, sneers and personal smears offer no transparency to the debate.
Rather than claiming all problems facing indigenous communities can somehow be solved with an enshrined (but so far undefined) Voice in The Constitution, they should explain why this can't be achieved by the numerous State and Federal indigenous agencies who have received copious funding over many years. This is shown in a direct quote from a Productivity Commission report: "Total direct expenditure on services for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians in 2012-13 was estimated to be $30.3 billion, accounting for 6.1% of total direct general government expenditure."
Advertisement
Where has all the money gone, Albo, if not to the outback communities in most need?
Meanwhile, there were 812,728 people who identified as Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander origin in the 2021 Census– up from 649,171 in 2016. This represents an increase of 25.2% or 163,557 and was higher than the increase between 2006 and 2011 (20.5%) and between 2011 and 2016 (18.4%).
You don't have to be a Rhodes Scholar to see the trend here. If the Yes vote succeeds, you can bet the house, if you're fortunate enough to own it, the surge of "box tickers" will overload the largesse of any government unless some meaningful checks put a stop to a blank cheque approach for those on the receiving end.
But wait, my grandfather, old Hans, arrived unaccompanied as a penniless teenage Danish immigrant back in the 1880s and worked alongside the Kanakas in the Bundaberg canefields before he eventually bought his own farms. Maybe he had a romp in the hay with a young Islander girl… Maybe there's a box I can tick as a new-found member of the expanding Gimmemunni Tribe.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
24 posts so far.