Like what you've read?

On Line Opinion is the only Australian site where you get all sides of the story. We don't
charge, but we need your support. Here�s how you can help.

  • Advertise

    We have a monthly audience of 70,000 and advertising packages from $200 a month.

  • Volunteer

    We always need commissioning editors and sub-editors.

  • Contribute

    Got something to say? Submit an essay.


 The National Forum   Donate   Your Account   On Line Opinion   Forum   Blogs   Polling   About   
On Line Opinion logo ON LINE OPINION - Australia's e-journal of social and political debate

Subscribe!
Subscribe





On Line Opinion is a not-for-profit publication and relies on the generosity of its sponsors, editors and contributors. If you would like to help, contact us.
___________

Syndicate
RSS/XML


RSS 2.0

Stirring the possum - eat to save the planet

By Geoff Russell - posted Thursday, 13 November 2008


Adelaide’s Hilton Hotel recently (October 30) hosted another in the South Australian Department of Environment’s “Stirring the Possum” series. “Eat to Save the Planet” was a hot topic and booked out within days of its announcement. The main speaker was Hilton and TV celebrity chef Simon Bryant. Others on the panel were permaculturalist Annemarie Brookman, Outback Pride co-creator Mike Quarmby and Balance Carbon Director, Dr Tim Moore.

Bryant was fascinating. I don’t watch his TV program, but this guy has thought about food a great deal. Among his more perceptive comments was that eating local is a two-way street. We live in a country that has milked the Murray down to mud to increase food exports. Should our motto really be “eat local, export global”? Of course, it is one thing to produce food to alleviate global food shortages but quite another to take that food and transform it into marbled beef for rich overseas consumers.

Quarmby and Brookman both have interesting personal stories of building solid businesses out of food in ways that are vastly different from the agribusinesses which fill our supermarkets. Think bush tucker and farmer’s markets. Moore was introduced as a boffin to add some now familiar graphs of greenhouse emissions to the mix.

Advertisement

What was missing from the event was almost anything relevant to the subject matter of the title.

Bryant gave “food miles” plenty of air time, but, as a questioner inconveniently pointed out towards the end of the event, food miles are just 10 per cent of greenhouse emissions. Missing was any discussion about whether organic food production, clearly favoured by the panel, can both save the planet and feed its inhabitants.

So why can’t organic farming cut it? Plants need nitrogen to make protein and there is a gap between the amount of nitrogen sucked from the sky by bacteria in some plant roots and the amount of protein consumed by the 6.7 billion punters. The gap is currently filled by artificial fertiliser, anathema to organic farmers, but without which scientists estimate that 3 billion people would not just be hungry, but dead.

Instead of serious attention to big issues, we got a focus on personal actions with no consideration of their scalability.

Consider kangaroos, praised by Bryant as having a small eco and welfare footprint and very much flavour of the month following their mention in the Garnaut review. Missing was the tiny gotcha that the yield of meat cuts from a kangaroo is just 1.5 kg with the rest being fit only for the kind of processed meat which the World Cancer Research Foundation is advising people to totally avoid because it is an even more potent cause of bowel cancer than ordinary red meat.

Apart from providing little food, we rarely manage to kill the annual quota of around three million kangaroos anyway. Why not? It seems that driving round all night in a 4WD shooting roos in the middle of nowhere isn’t high on the list of cool jobs. As for the eco-padprint, those kangaroos may indeed have soft pads, but try kicking the tyres or paying the fuel bill of a ’roo shooters 4WD sometime.

Advertisement

By contrast, we easily manage to kill 455 million chickens annually and each one produces a similar amount of meat to a kangaroo. Would kangaroos be environmentally benign if we had the 2.5 billion animals that would be required for an annual kill of 455 million to replace chickens? Absolutely not.

Then there was the cheese incident. The Hilton Foyer was filled for the event with organic food displays with a number featuring cheese. Given that the dairy industry is far and away the biggest milker of Murray Darling Basin water, and a grass fed dairy cow can produce three times the methane of a grain fed feedlot beast, organic or not, it was no surprise when an audience member asked whether this was a contradiction.

This prompted a spirited defence of the Hilton’s cheese supplier by Bryant and then Tim Moore dropped the “V” word. He revealed he’d like to be vegan but just couldn’t resist cheese. Once the “V” word escaped, the rest of the panel shinnied up the rigging and prepared to repel borders with the usual irrelevancies: “We have always killed and eaten animals”, “We are at the top of the food chain”, “The food chain is brutal”. Any pretence at objective consideration of the real issues vanished.

The global average per capita annual greenhouse emission is 6.8 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalents, this includes, food, housing, transport ... everything. The average Aussie diet generates 6 tonnes all by itself. It isn’t high because of food miles or artificial fertiliser or pesticides. It is high because of meat and dairy.

Globally, animal products consume the entire output of a third of all arable land, plus 3,400 million hectares of grazing land, plus the entire (but declining) output of all the world’s fisheries, but produce just 17 per cent of global calories. So if anybody is seriously interested in eating to save the planet, then all the issues surrounding meat and dairy production are central.

Apart from being an astonishingly inefficient and polluting food source, livestock is the largest driver of deforestation and biodiversity loss both globally and locally. Livestock has caused 70 per cent of Amazon deforestation compared with just 3 per cent (yes, just three) due to logging. Locally, livestock has caused the bulk of extinctions and deforestation in Australia. Even as late as the 1990s, the Queensland cattle industry was deforesting over 400,000 hectares annually.

It is interesting to compare the panel’s response to the “V” word with the response when people concerned with climate change suggest we should drive less or, better still, be car free and stick to bicycles and public transport. Everybody just recognises this as blindingly obviously the correct thing to do - even if we can’t all manage it. But recommend eating less or no meat and dairy and the irrelevant non-sequiturs pour forth from otherwise rational people like blood from a stuck pig.

But despite the avoidance of its topic, the event was a raging success. Host Alan Holmes, head of the SA Department of Environment, joined the rest of the audience and purred like a kitten at talk of all the positive things which individuals can do to “make a difference”.

Of course he would. Governments and their lackeys love this stuff, just like they love talk of buying new light globes and smaller washing machine to combat global warming. Such attitudes absolve them from tackling the hard issues like replacing the dairy, beef and coal industries. They can continue to let fast food giants supply the bulk of food which poisons the planet and children while treating international guests to $29 ’roo saddle at the Hilton.

Eventually the possum nodded off, hardly shaken and definitely not stirred.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. All

An ABC podcast of the event can be found here. Geoff has a critique of Tim Flannery's recent Quarterly Essay, "Now or Never", which will appear in the next Quarterly Essay, due out in early December.



Discuss in our Forums

See what other readers are saying about this article!

Click here to read & post comments.

22 posts so far.

Share this:
reddit this reddit thisbookmark with del.icio.us Del.icio.usdigg thisseed newsvineSeed NewsvineStumbleUpon StumbleUponsubmit to propellerkwoff it

About the Author

Geoff is a mathematician and computer programmer and is a member of Animal Liberation SA. He has been published in The Monthly, The Age, Australasian Science, Independent Weekly and Dissent. His latest book GreenJacked has just been published.

Other articles by this Author

All articles by Geoff Russell

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Photo of Geoff Russell
Article Tools
Comment 22 comments
Print Printable version
Subscribe Subscribe
Email Email a friend
Advertisement

About Us Search Discuss Feedback Legals Privacy