Does established religion have anything to say to the modern world?
Yes, in the manner that all human inventions, be they Roman law,
Aboriginal rock art, Greek myths or Hindu temples tell us about our
cultural history. No, if we ask whether established religion provides the
best available understanding with which to answer life's big questions:
Who are we? Where did we come from? Where are we going? How shall we live?
Established religions like Christianity, Hinduism, Islam and Judaism
encapsulate beliefs from times when human knowledge was much more limited,
when disease was attributed to evil spirits, and natural disasters to the
wrath of god(s). Neither the vastness of the universe, nor the totality of
our planet Earth was known. Transport was slow, distant communication
likewise. When people lived in tribal communities and believed themselves
to be special beings, the big questions were resolved by inventing
religious dogmas such as "god created man in his image",
"the one true faith", "god's chosen people",
"life after death" and "man has dominion over
animals". People not of one's group could be ill-treated or killed
with impunity, and nature ravaged as though it was infinite.
We now live in different times. The great expansion of human knowledge,
produced by the self-correcting methods of science, has resulted in the
control of disease, abundant food, instant global communication, rapid
transport, and many other advances. We know much about our finite planet
and the vastness of the universe. We know humans are a naturally evolved
life form dependent on the Earth's biosphere for survival. We also know
that all humans, though diverse in appearance and culture, are members of
the same species.
Advertisement
In today's globalised world many people are working for outcomes
inspired by secular humanist ideas: that all humans are equal, regardless
of gender, ethnicity, social and economic status and life beliefs, and
that resources should be shared more equitably and natural ecosystems
conserved. Growing numbers believe that these humanist aspirations are
essential for the wellbeing and continuance of our species. Yet, despite
increased knowledge and the evidence of human-caused damage, responsible
action on social and environmental problems is being hampered by
established religion. For example, opposition to equality (especially for
women), to family planning, to universal human rights, and to the need for
resource sharing and conservation.
What, then, is a modern answer to "Who are we?" Science tells
us we are made up of the same matter as the rest of the universe, whether
a star, rock, plant or animal. Our structure, functioning and behaviour
are like that of other life forms. The more closely related, the greater
the resemblance, e.g. we share 98 per cent of our genetic material with
chimpanzees, our nearest relative. Such similarities have enabled great
advances in medical science through the use of experimental animals to
test procedures and drugs. What makes us different and unique is not some
imagined extra ingredient, like an immortal soul, but rather a combination
of naturally evolved capacities, such as tool use, sociability, language,
reflective thinking and the development of culture. Thus we are
intelligent, emotional, creative and highly sociable animals. We engage in
the arts, science, story telling, politics, philosophy, technology, games
and sport, and celebrate the creativity of the Bachs, Newtons, Picassos
and Shakespeares of our cultural world.
So, "Where did we come from?" Science reveals that, like
other life forms, we evolved naturally. When we took to walking upright,
our hands were freed to shape tools, make objects, build houses, write,
paint, etc. In combination with language use and large brains, this led to
the sort of being we are today: a product of evolution, capable of
reflecting on who we are, why we are here and what it all means. In the
earlier stages of our cultural evolution, humans invented religious
answers and attributed our origins and life purpose to supernatural
entities. Now that we have invented science, our most authentic answers
come from investigating our surroundings and ourselves.
What about "Where are we going?" It is not to an imagined
heaven, hell or to be reincarnated. Instead, when we die, social
relationships are grievously disrupted and our body is decomposed into
simpler elements for reuse. Life after death, though much yearned for, is
just wishful thinking. Apart from being a contradiction, it is an idea for
which there is no convincing evidence. We do 'live on' in the memory of
those still living, while where we are going collectively is, in part,
ours to determine.
In summary, the scientific worldview is far more satisfying, inspiring
and useable than the archaic beliefs of religion. In fact, even
established religions have largely accepted the authoritative answers of
science to the first three big questions. This leaves only the fourth
question - How shall we live? - to be contested.
The ethics and values we try to live by are an extension of the way we
understand the world and our place in it. The humanist recognition that
humans have evolved naturally, are all of the same species, and will live
only once, gives rise to the ethics and values of equality, fairness and
justice. Instead of trying to lead a good life to appease an imagined God,
or get to heaven, a growing number of people try to lead a good life by
recognising our responsibility for the wellbeing of all humanity and of
other life forms. These people draw on human wisdom which shows that
acting with compassion, empathy and tolerance, settling disputes by talk
rather than violence, and being prudent and restrained will lead to the
most peaceful, just and socially productive outcomes.
Advertisement
It is those who cling to the certainties of established religion that
cause the most havoc in today's troubled world: the Catholic and Islamic
resistance to family-planning programs, the Palestinian/Israel conflict,
terrorism inspired by fundamentalist beliefs, religion-based conflict, and
the US belief that god is on their side. In contrast, modern humanism
rests on the open-mindedness of science and the desire to use human
capabilities to develop a more just and equitable world.