There is no question Governor General Peter Hollingworth
should resign. If he refuses, as he has so far, Prime
Minister John Howard must dismiss him.
The Governor General has clearly lost the support
of the Australian public. Australians, largely, are
primarily and justifiably aghast at Dr Hollingworth's
defence that failing to act appropriately on cases of
child sexual abuse reported to him while Anglican Archbishop
of Brisbane was just an error of judgement.
Such a defence continues to send the message that
child sexual assault is not that important. Victims
of sexual assault are effectively being told to "get
over it" and get on with their lives.
Advertisement
The reality is that thousands of survivors of abuse
are not able to get on with their lives because the
crimes committed against them have never been properly
acknowledged or addressed.
There is a need for a strong statement to be sent
to all Australians that covering up for the perpetrators
of child sexual assault is totally unacceptable, that
dismissing the complaints of victims is equally unacceptable. Dr Hollingworth's actions and his response to the Anglican Inquiry sends the opposite message - and that is unacceptable.
The Prime Minister and the Governor General are effectively
saying that the Anglican Church Inquiry's findings do
not involve matters of sufficient concern to compromise
the integrity of the highest office in our land.
I disagree. Child sexual assault is one of the most
serious of issues, particularly when the perpetrating
and covering-up of such crimes is endemic and institutionalised,
as it clearly has been in many cases.
The office of Governor General is one of the most
significant in Australia. Dr Hollingworth serves in
a position that should be unifying for our nation. It
is a position that should portray compassion, empathy
and the best of Australian character.
It is a unique and special position, which is why
unique requirements attach to it. Losing faith in the
office of Governor General is very serious - it can
compromise our system of government and diminish us
as a nation.
Advertisement
Dr Hollingworth is the focus of this crisis, but
the issue is far larger than the behaviour of one man.
Yet it falls to Dr Hollingworth and Mr Howard - men
who have so far failed to adequately take a stand against
child sexual abuse - to grab this chance to make significant
change and set in concrete the boundaries of appropriate
behaviour when it comes to protecting children.
What is required is a clean sweep. Mr Howard must
ensure Dr Hollingworth departs as Governor General,
and then establish a Judicial Inquiry or Royal Commission
into the issue of sexual abuse of children in care.
Such an inquiry will inescapably expose ugly secrets
of child suffering in Australian institutions. It will
ensure better protection for children in the present
and the future. It may, perhaps, allow for justice and
the horrendous scars of victims of child sexual abuse
to begin to heal.
The Democrats will not desist in pressuring for such
an inquiry, nor retreat from calls for Dr Hollingworth
to resign.
The excuse that Dr Hollingworth was just part of
a system or of a time in which churches across the board
didn't handle allegations of sexual abuse against priests
very well - as has been suggested by some - is not acceptable.
We are talking about actions and statements that occurred
quite recently. In any case, never has there been a
time when turning a blind eye to reports of sexual abuse
of a child was OK.
This is no "witch-hunt". Nor is it "mob
hysteria". People are right to speak of the need
to protect the rights of the accused as well as those
who make allegations.
But, as with any other public office, this is a public
debate about a person's suitability to hold that office.
Dr Hollingworth failed in his duty of care to children
and the rights of the victims have been ignored.
It is time we as a nation gave first priority to
protecting the rights of children.