Contrary to what you will hear from supporters
of the American pre-emptive war against
Iraq, Australia's strategic environment
has deteriorated disastrously over the
last few days. We are now one of a three-member
international cabal, which wages war unsanctioned
by the United Nations.
True, the strongest member of this cabal
is the strongest nation on earth but,
as its weakest member by far, we invite
attack.
Both the US and UK governments have at
least recognised that their attack on
Iraq will fuel the threat of terrorism
directed at them, their interests and
their people. Here in Australia John Howard
remains in firm denial mode. It is ironic
that about the only utterance of George
W. Bush not echoed by John Howard has
been Bush's warning of heightened terrorist
threats as a result of the war.
Advertisement
It is all very well to argue that destroying
the Saddam regime will remove a source
of state support for terrorism. As far
as it goes this is true, though the US
soldiers who wrote "9-11" on
artillery shells destined for Iraqi targets
are sadly misled if they seriously believe
that Saddam's regime had anything to do
with the 11 September 2001 atrocities.
But terrorism has never needed state
support to flourish. Rather, it requires
a population with a grievance, real or
imagined, strong enough to justify terror
tactics. The grievances of many Arabs
and Muslims against the US and its shrunken
band of close collaborators have been
greatly exacerbated by the present war.
Because Australia is a member of this
band, because it is remote from the other
two and because it is by far the weakest
of the aggressive cabal, it is especially
vulnerable.
Moreover, Australia has isolated itself
in its region. It will be years, at least,
before any neighbour will accept that
Australia has anything of its own to contribute
to the region. Henceforth, though neighbours
may diplomatically refrain from saying
so publicly, we will be seen as an arm
of the US with no credible independent
foreign and security policy. We may differ
from Washington on nuances, details, minor
security issues but our servile support
for Washington has destroyed any pretensions
we may have had towards being taken seriously
as an independent actor.
Some commentators have seized on the
concept of Australia supplying so-called
"niche" or specialised military
capabilities to US-led operations. This
is in fact an accurate description of
our role in the Iraq war and is all too
revealing as to the future function of
our military. Any suggestion that our
Defence Force exists to support our own
security, to add weight to our diplomacy,
is now obsolete. We are a small - not
irreplaceable - cog in the military machine
of American global hegemony.
We will be told - indeed, the Prime Minister
said almost as much when he addressed
the nation at the start of the war - that
we are doing this to earn "brownie
points" in Washington. For what these
points can be redeemed is still unclear.
Advertisement
Is it military security against aggressors?
But both the Prime Minister and Defence
Minister Senator Hill are on record as
saying that traditional threats from
conventional military aggressors are not
an issue for us; that these threats are
in recession.
Is it a better deal on trade? Some have
suggested that the Prime Minister thinks
he can get a good Free Trade Agreement
with Washington by tapping its gratitude
for our support. In fairness, Mr Howard
himself has not said this; he would be
mistaken in any case if he thought that
Washington would ever sell out its farm
lobby in order to satisfy ours. Trade
talks have always revealed the limits
of US gratitude for Australian help, and
always will.
Since 1945 we have fought with the US
in Korea, Indochina, the 1991 Gulf War,
Afghanistan and now in Iraq. What have
they done for us lately? We wanted US
ground forces in East Timor. We could
not get them and were forced to stretch
our limited military resources to help
the East Timorese.
It is bad enough that this war is unsanctioned
and unnecessary, but its adverse effects
on our long-term security and regional
credibility will be far worse. We have
made ourselves a member of a very small
and select club; the dues are billions
of dollars in fancy weaponry and a heightened
profile as a target for all enemies of
the United States. Henceforth their enemies
are ours.
Welcome to Australia, a minor and expendable
province of the American Empire. The local
Imperial Governor is named John Howard.