The alternative is endless friction, wasted resources and the risk of miscalculation among nuclear powers. Dialogue among the three, however preliminary, is preferable to mutual isolation and proxy escalation.
Comparisons with Yalta fail for another reason. In 1945 the victors of a total war sat down to shape a devastated international system. Today the system is intact but strained. The three powers are not wartime allies dividing spoils but rivals and intermittent partners seeking to manage competition.
The Shenzhen meeting can be better understood as the opening of a process rather than its culmination. Putin indicated afterwards that further meetings should follow. Trump has repeatedly signalled interest in nuclear discussions. Xi has positioned China as a stabilising force while advancing its own vision of multipolarity and "greater democracy in international relations." Whether these intentions produce substantive follow-up remains to be seen. What matters is that the conversation has begun on terms that no longer assume American monopolarity.
Advertisement
Western analysis has focused heavily on what was not achieved, such as detailed progress on Ukraine or Iran, or concrete cuts in nuclear arsenals. That focus is understandable but incomplete. Great-power diplomacy often begins with symbolism and process before substance. The very act of the three leaders sitting together as equals, in a Chinese city that embodies technological modernity, signals to the rest of the world that the old hierarchy has loosened. Middle powers, the Global South, and regional organisations will take note. They will calibrate their own policies accordingly.
The United States now faces a strategic choice. It can treat multipolarity as an unacceptable challenge to be rolled back through tariffs, alliances of containment and technological denial. Or it can accept the structural shift already underway and seek to shape the emerging order through engagement, selective cooperation and hard-headed defence of its core interests.
Shenzhen suggested that Trump may be open to the second path, at least in personal diplomacy. Whether Washington's broader political and bureaucratic system follows is another question.
History will not record the Shenzhen summit as a grand bargain that settled the world's disputes. It was not designed to be one. It will be remembered, if the follow-up materialises, as the moment the three principal powers of the early twenty-first century publicly acknowledged that the post-Cold War unipolar moment had ended. The circular table in Shenzhen was a stage, but the performance reflected a deeper redistribution of power. The United States is no longer the sole architect of the international system. It is one of its principal stakeholders. Accepting that fact is the first step toward managing the competition that will define the decades ahead.
The alternative is clinging to an outdated map of power, which is a recipe for friction without purpose. Shenzhen was not Yalta. It was something more useful: an early, imperfect signal that the world has already moved on. We need to watch what Trump does over the next few weeks to see, whether he will continue in his bombastic direction, or heed the new opportunity hinted to him at Shenzen.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.