Australia and New Zealand owe Europe part of their history, not control of their future. That kinship deserves respect, but it need not dictate commercial priorities. Across the Pacific, Latin America offers the prospect of a more ambitious relationship between partners with something to offer each other. The question extends well beyond another agreement with Brussels. It is about choosing the partners with whom to build the prosperity of the coming decades.
When I speak of European decline, I am questioning a way of exercising power, not the intelligence of Europe's citizens. I mean a political leadership that has perfected the art of explaining its failures while losing the will to correct them. It promises protection, multiplies restrictions and then seems surprised when investment looks elsewhere. Preserving inherited wealth is not enough when the ability to create more has weakened.
The warning does not come from Europe's critics alone. Addressing the European Parliament in September 2024, Mario Draghi noted that EU companies faced electricity prices two to three times those paid by their American and Chinese competitors. He also highlighted Europe's technological lag. It is an uncomfortable admission for those who presume to instruct the rest of the world on progress. Speeches cannot restore competitiveness while obscuring the decisions that undermined it.
Advertisement
My criticism of the European left goes to the heart of its political approach. Its formula of multiplying public promises while mistrusting those expected to pay for them has, in my view, run its course. The centre right does not escape responsibility by adopting the same habits with better manners. Both must answer for their results. I expect leaders who keep offering regulations instead of opportunities eventually to encounter at the ballot box the limits they refused to recognise in office.
Schumpeter explained the importance of innovation and productive transformation to capitalism. His argument sits uneasily with those who would immobilise an economy to preserve established positions. A society can retain its buildings, ceremonies and solemn institutions while losing the impetus that made them possible. Managing an inheritance is not the same as securing its future.
Oceania's trade agreements allow us to examine this problem in practical terms. Australia concluded negotiations with the European Union on 24 March 2026, although the agreement is not yet in force. New Zealand's agreement took effect on 1 May 2024. Their circumstances differ, but both raise a question about reciprocity. The removal of numerous tariffs coexists with quotas on agricultural products Europe regards as sensitive.
New Zealand removed all tariffs on EU goods when its agreement entered into force. Preferential access to Europe for certain New Zealand products, including beef and several dairy products, remains subject to quotas. Agricultural quotas also feature in Australia's agreement. Brussels is remarkably fluent in the language of openness, provided it is not asked to open its own doors too wide.
Alongside this sits the Common Agricultural Policy, backed by €307 billion in public funding for 2023 to 2027, including EU and national funds. Australia's National Farmers' Federation has challenged the adequacy of the market access offered against the support enjoyed by European producers. That objection deserves a hearing, not a dismissal. Asking for reciprocity is hardly a rejection of trade. It is a refusal to mistake a diplomatic photograph for a satisfactory commercial bargain.
New Zealand has, of course, increased its exports to the EU since its agreement came into force, as its government reports. I welcome those sales. That is precisely why I want to widen the options, not close them. No commercial success gives Europe an exclusive claim on either country's strategic attention. Selling to Europe need not mean acquiring its political complacency as part of the transaction.
Advertisement
Consider the scale of the alternative. The UN Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean puts Latin America's population at about 655 million in 2025. The EU had roughly 451 million people at the start of that year, according to Eurostat. The difference exceeds 200 million. It would be naive to equate population with purchasing power, but equally absurd to treat a market of that size as a peripheral curiosity. Its consumers, businesses and needs warrant more than a ceremonial visit.
What I propose is a partnership of capabilities. Australian and New Zealand expertise in mining services, agricultural technology, education, water and energy can find business and scientific partners in Latin America. Our region also brings knowledge and solutions. A mature relationship should move beyond routine commodity exchanges towards joint ventures, industrial processing and access to markets that would be harder to reach separately.
There is already a foundation to build on. Australia and New Zealand share membership of the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership with Chile, Mexico and Peru. They should make better use of it and deepen ties with other Latin American countries. Economic diplomacy earns its keep through the opportunities it creates, not the number of documents it adds to a ministry's archives.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
1 post so far.