Flirting with nuclear energy down under

In his second budget reply speech in May, Dutton showed little sign of being briefed on these problems, stating that "any sensible government [in the 21^st century] must consider small modular nuclear as part of the energy mix." Labor's policies on climate change had resulted in placing Australia "on the wrong energy path."

Such views have not impressed the Albanese Government. Energy Minister Chris Bowen insists that counterfeit claims are being peddled on the issue of the role played by nuclear energy in Canada along with false distinctions between the costs of nuclear power and renewable energy.

"If they are serious about proposing a nuclear solution for Australia, the simplistic bumper stickers and populist echo chamber has to come to an end. Show the Australian people your verified nuclear costings and your detailed plans about where the nuclear power plants will go."

Such verification will be a tall order indeed. As the CSIRO concedes, "Without more real-world data for SMRs demonstrating that nuclear can be economically viable, the debate will likely continue to be dominated by opinion and conflicting social values rather than a discussion on the underlying assumptions."