But differing views on religion should not be resolved through civil law suits.
My view on this is not new or recent. In 1994 I opposed a proposed Commonwealth Bill on Racial Vilification on the following grounds:
The legislation is going to make certain subjects very difficult to discuss in an open way. It is going to vest a large supervisory role in government appointees over exactly what can or cannot be said.
Advertisement
At the time I was worried that "vilification" legislation would inhibit free discussion of important political issues. Since then the Victorian Parliament has passed the Act dealing with racial and religious "vilification". No one likes vilification.
We are an open and tolerant society. But if rival camps start sending informants to rival meetings so they can take legal proceedings against each other in publicly funded tribunals we shall not enhance our openness or tolerance.
The proceedings which have been taken, the time, the cost, the extent of the proceedings, the remedies that are available all illustrate, in my view, that this is a bad law.
We would be better to forget the litigation and work to reinforce the values drawn from the tradition that underlies our society - respect for individuals, tolerance within a framework of law, and mutual respect.
This is the legacy of our Judeo-Christian tradition.
Unfortunately today we see that legacy fraying all around us. It is almost as if the capital deposit has been drawn down for such regular maintenance that the capital is running out. The maintenance demands are unending. But we are not building up the capital required to service it.
Advertisement
We do not have to look far to see evidence of moral decay around us. We can see it and hear it in entertainment like rap music, in songs which glorify violence or suicide or exploitation of others.
As we speak drug barons compete for the distribution rights to sell drugs to our children in Melbourne. These rights are so lucrative that they are prepared to kill to protect their profits - with 24 or 25 unsolved gangland murders in Victoria since 1998.
These barons sell young people into addiction. Drugs break up families and marriages. Many addicts end up in prostitution or burglary. These outcomes are the very antitheses of all those values set out in the Ten Commandments about how to order society.
This is an edited version of a speech to the National Day of Thanksgiving commemoration at Scots Church, Melbourne on 29 may 2004. The original Speech can be found here.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
2 posts so far.