Was it a foregone conclusion?
I was unsurprised at the AMA executive's continued opposition to assisted dying. The signals were clear.
While the policy review was in play, AMA President Dr Michael Gannon made a series of tweets and media comments, all unsupportive of or directly opposed to assisted dying. Here's a few.
In response to an article in The Australian "Catholic stance allows eased exit", he tweeted a faux 'competition' between palliative care and assisted dying:
Advertisement
13 Aug 2016: Different views society on assisted dying. Hope all agree improved PalliativeCare access a priority @westaustralian
He also tweeted in support of the 'doctrine of double effect', a controversial policy (which the AMA promotes as uncontroversial) that contends it's quite OK for a doctor to hasten a patient's death after all… provided they don't really mean to: hardly a robust or verifiable standard.
24 Aug 2016: Doctors should be careful, must obey the law and understand their code of #ethics. Double effect is not #Euthanasia
In an article in The Australian on 15th September, Dr Gannon argued against assisted dying on the basis of it being 'extremely complex.' If complexity were a reason to oppose anything, the AMA would be opposed to the entire healthcare system: it's incredibly complex. His argument collapses at the slightest inspection.
18 Sep 2016: Hippocratic medicine older than some of the world's great religions, every political ideology, trend #ethics @medwma
Dr Gannon then invokes the Hippocratic Oath, which bans assisted dying. That's cherry-picking at its best: doctors do not take the Hippocratic Oath: it swears allegiance to ancient Greek gods, forbids women from entering the profession and outlaws surgery, amongst other things.
Advertisement
19 Sep 2016: Agree @DrSallyCockburn admire #euthanasia work done by @CMA_Docs. Equally careful, compassionate, intelligent approach from @TheBMA #ethics
He commends the British Medical Association's "intelligent approach" against assisted dying: an approach I have comprehensively exposedas superficial and ill-informed fear-mongering, fiction, flip-flop and hubris.
1 Oct 2016: It is inevitable that if #Euthanasia laws are passed, they will over time be expanded to include children, mentally ill, vulnerable #ethic
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
6 posts so far.