The queen confronts X Hadi

It's obvious the two men have credibility problems. They tell different stories. To Western ears some elements sound fantastic

Riyan says he was picked up in Jakarta and offered Rp 15 million (AUD $1,500) to help take the boat to Probolinggo for sale. He claims ignorance of people smuggling.

Prosecutor Anthony Eyers makes much of the fact that Riyan was earning only Rp 25,000 (AUD $2.50) a day fishing. So he surely knew something illegal was planned when 600 days income was proposed by an unnamed 'friend' for four days work.

Hadi says he didn't get paid and hadn't negotiated a salary. Mr Eyers, and presumably the jury, think this incredible. Hadi protests that Indonesian lads don't question or quibble.

He also says he knew nothing about destination Australia. But the boat was carrying ample water and food along with lifejackets and mattresses for 57, not three.

Even if he hadn't noticed the gear and supplies why didn't Hadi jump up,when the Afghans clambered aboard like phantoms in the darkness, shouting: 'Hey boss, this isn't right – I want out!'

He tells the court he was seasick at the time. He didn't add that even if he'd been fit and brave it probably wouldn't have made any difference.

Hadi might have avoided court if he'd held to earlier claims to be under 18. If proven he'd have been flownback to his Mum in Solo.

"We're dealing here with poor, almost illiterate village people," said Indonesia Institute president Ross Taylor outside the court. "They have no understanding of the risks and consequences.

"Australia is running a deterrent policy and the kids are the victims. The real people smugglers exploit Australia's decency and commitment to human rights – and stay in Jakarta."

At the Indonesian Consulate-General office Chancery head Syahri Sakidin said Hadi tired of constant questions about his age. "In prison he gets good food, high quality medical care, and earns AUD $30 a week doing kitchen chores," he said

Hadi and Riyan are with other Indonesians and apparently get on well with staff and prisoners. Indonesian is now the most common foreign language in WA jails.