British Actress, Comedian, broadcaster, Liz Carr, known internationally for her work opposing assisted suicide as a disability campaigner as well as her role in the BBC forensics drama, Silent Witness, has been in Melbourne, Australia for the last few weeks with her show: Assisted Suicide: The Musical.
Part of the Melbourne International Comedy Festival, Liz's show is incredibly funny as it is poignant. Simply put; it is a great night out designed to make people think about the issue of assisted suicide. Pegged by Liz as a 'Ted Talk with show tunes' the show is a rollicking feast of songs in the great tradition of show tunes interspersed with Liz talking to the audience about her experiences and concerns about assisted suicide.
John Counsel summarized well in his review:
For me, the lasting impression was of how reasonable Liz's arguments are. There's no dogmatic, in-your-face demand to accept any specific position. Yes, there's plenty of confrontation and strong language… but it's not directed against anything except entrenched, predominantly-emotional stances that simply won't stand up to rational examination. And she covers just about every imaginable angle. The overwhelming take-out from this 90-minute entertainment is just how ill-considered and irrational most of the pro-suicide arguments really are, and how rational and reasonable the alternatives are. It's about LIFE, not death. And it's about showing better solutions for LIVING with dignity.
She also skewers popular pro-suicide buzzwords like "choice", "dying with dignity", "mercy killing", etc and presents a cogent case for people with disabilities, against a clever tapestry of the stark realities experienced in countries and states around the world where assisted suicide is already legal. It's a sobering wake-up call, delivered with clinical precision, couched in terms that can only be considered rational and lucid - yet disarmingly kind and intensely human."
Each night in the auditorium a lonely, empty chair faces Liz and the cast during each performance. A sign on the chair reads:
Following an invitation from Liz Carr and Company - RESERVED - Premier Daniel Andrews.
The chair has remained empty.
A cynic might conclude that the empty chair and the sign itself are something of a 'trick-of-the-trade'; a vaudevillian artifice to add some extra dimension to the performance. To know Liz Carr would be to instantly dismiss such accusations. After all, the show is all about bringing information and experience to the debate which includes all politicians and certainly the Premier of Victoria. As Western Australian disability advocate, Sam Connor told the South Australian Parliament last year, 'We don't have loud voices; we don't have unlimited funds; we don't have glossy campaigns; we don't have articulate public figures...and that's why you need to listen harder because we are the people that are going to die as a result of this legislation.' That is one reason why Liz Carr's show is so important and why behaving like the proverbial ostrich is both disrespectful an dangerous.
Other Members of Parliament have seen the show and others also joined with their colleagues to hear Liz give a briefing in Parliament before the show commenced. Not all will have had an open mind on the subject, certainly; but to their credit they heard Liz out. And if informed consent is to be the hallmark of access to assisted suicide legislation, then surely giving up 90 minutes one evening to become informed about the issues that many in the disability community hold in this matter isn't too much to ask? As Liz told Victorian MPs recently:
Opposition to these bills is usually marginalised as being religious and that's very useful to do if you don't want to listen to it, but actually if we want to introduce a bill like this, we have to listen to all sides of course, and we have to not diminish their view."
I have met with disabled people all over the world in this issue. Why does it involve us? Because it's very easy to shut up disabled people, and go this is not about you. This is about terminally ill people. In the public perception, in the media, and in medical terms there is such a fine line between disability and terminal illness, that we become one in the same."
Nor is Liz's attempt to engage Premier Andrews about trying to embarrass him into coming. Liz has contacted the Premier's office with an invitation; she has invited him again and again on social media, on national television and in the pages of the local newspapers. This is about genuine and necessary engagement with the issues; about an informed decision.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
2 posts so far.
Paul is also Vice Chair of the International Euthanasia Prevention Coalition