National Forum   Support   Your Account   Journal   Forums   The Domain   iParliament   Issues Briefs   Consultations   About TNF   
On Line Opinion logo ON LINE OPINION - Australia's e-journal of social and political debate

Subscribe!
Subscribe













On Line Opinion is a not-for-profit publication and relies on the generosity of its sponsors, editors and contributors. If you would like to help, contact us.
___________

Syndicate
RSS/XML


RSS 2.0
May 12, 2008
This self satisfied attitude of 'if its not in English then it can’t be worth saying' is a form of global provincialism.
Feature - Paul Doolan - 14 comments
 
The Greens are less of an environmental movement and more of a left wing conglomeration devoted primarily to social justice issues.
Environment - Peter Ridd - 36 comments
 
A HECS-style loan scheme could help people in their time of need, but also would expect them to give back when times are good.
Economics - Andrew Leigh - 2 comments
 
Ideological intransigence - as displayed at the 2020 ‘Health’ Summit - won’t relieve the pressures on younger generations as the population ages.
Health - Jeremy Sammut - 1 comment
 
Let's offer refugees classes to teach them about their new home rather than exams.
Society - Peter van Vliet
 
A first practical step towards reconciliation in Australia would be to teach a local Aboriginal language in schools.
Feature - Brian Manning - 8 comments
 
Cartoon
A. Moir of "The Sydney Morning Herald"
www.moir.com.au

Featured Topic - May
Languages at school

May Feature - Languages at schoolWhat's the point of language teaching? Is it just economic, or are the biggest benefits intrinsic? What languages should be taught, how should we determine priorities? And what about "dead" and invented languages like Latin and Es ...

Read More

Call for Contributions - June Feature
Food for thought

Send your submission to the editorThe world is now consuming more food than it produces. Is this irreversible or can man's ingenuity continue to feed us all?

Please send submissions to the editor.

Our Members




Ambit Gambit - Our blog
Liberal President "dishonest" - Vice-President

Ambit Gambit Liberal Party interim president Gary Spence has been accused of dishonestly misrepresenting the views of members of the party's state council, of fabrication and flagrant misrepresentation. One of the mysteries of reports of last Friday's Liberal Party State Council was...

Read More

Advertisement

Associates
Henry Thornton




Today's Most Popular Articles
»  The Greens: illogical and treacherous
»  The Great Barrier Reef and the prophets of doom
»  Ignorant of the fact of being ignorant
»  Teach instead of test
»  What’s the point of teaching languages?
This Week's Most Popular
»  The Great Barrier Reef and the prophets of doom
»  Implanon: just slip it in?
»  The sluts-r-us approach to childhood play
»  The plight of the Great Barrier Reef
»  Branding girls for s*x
This Week's Most Discussed
»  Racism for the mainstream
»  Make a stand for good science
»  A genuine secular democracy would not be so insecure
»  The sluts-r-us approach to childhood play
»  The Greens: illogical and treacherous


Friday, May 9, 2008

The vilification of Islam, particularly in the West, has developed into something of a pseudo-intellectual industry.
Political Philosophy - Mustafa Qadri - 64 comments
 
We should be able to present arguments in defence of our faith and also our point of view, even if this is unpopular.
Religion & Spirituality - Keysar Trad - 45 comments
 
There are times, in war or during emergencies, when individual rights have to suffer for the good of the whole.
Law & Liberties - John Spender - 19 comments
 
Australia is one of the most successful multilingual and multicultural countries in the world: we should be tapping in to this valuable resource.
Feature - Joe Lo Bianco - 7 comments
 
In this US election cycle, the shadows of three past presidents - Reagan, Clinton and Bush - loom large.
International - Ciaran Ryan - 13 comments
 
Understanding an intimate relationship: the adult man exists in a relationship with his mother that can’t be resolved.
Society - Peter West - 11 comments
 

Thursday, May 8, 2008

Even the more extreme model projections only depict tropical oceanic warming still well within the limits that thriving reefs tolerate.
Environment - Walter Starck - 8 comments
 
Scientists must work harder at making the public aware of the stark difference between good science and denialist spin.
Science & Technology - Barry Brook - 47 comments
 
A new virtual fashion game gives young girls the message that their ultimate aim in life is to be a bimbo.
Media - Melinda Tankard Reist - 39 comments
 
If Peter Garrett went into politics to make a difference (and one assumes that he did) the Traveston Dam will be a crucial test of his determination.
Environment - Jenny Stewart - 10 comments
 
They want to put a gas pipeline through your property? So much for ownership, or at least the little person's ownership, and the right of refusal.
Law & Liberties - Kellie Tranter - 1 comment
 
A universal language is a tool for international communication, which respects and ensures the continuity of all national tongues, dialects, and idioms.
Feature - Henriette Vanechop - 14 comments
 

Wednesday, May 7, 2008

By 2050 the Great Barrier Reef will be unrecognisable. Bacterial slime, largely devoid of life, will be everywhere.
Environment - Charlie Veron - 10 comments
 
The Haneef inquiry may be a wasted exercise. When reputations, careers and organisational interests are at stake, voluntary co-operation quickly declines.
Law & Liberties - Scott Prasser - 17 comments
 
There is no need to tighten monetary policy after the March quarter's inflation figures - and no need to abandon or modify the inflation target either.
Economics - Saul Eslake - 4 comments
 
Learning a second language gives us an improved understanding the world, as much as it helps us to be understood.
Feature - Claudia Mainard - 27 comments
 
Despite its flaws, the Summit was a great success. It was an experiment in a new way of doing politics in Australia.
Domestic Politics - George Williams - 3 comments
 
Kevin Rudd has made a commitment to report annually on his government's efforts in closing the gap of Indigenous disadvantage.
Indigenous Affairs - Stephen Hagan - 2 comments
 

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

With an over-heated economy and powerful demand for labour, a wages surge would in times past be under way by now.
Economics - Henry Thornton - 8 comments
 
The more information we place online and the less discriminating we are, the greater the risk of exposure to ID theft and more.
Media - Andrew Barkla - 1 comment
 
A contraceptive quick fix does nothing to address sexual abuse in Indigenous communities.
Indigenous Affairs - Melinda Tankard Reist - 18 comments
 
Implanon may be the new 'cool' contraceptive but it has some side effects that are worth noting.
Health - Renate Klein - 4 comments
 
Visions for Australian society and economy: what makes a 'Good Society' and should such a thing be measured in purely material terms?
Society - Tristan Ewins - 29 comments
 
Esperanto is the best choice for a general primary school strategy for LOTE in Australia.
Feature - Penny Vos - 16 comments
 

Monday, May 5, 2008

An ice age is definitely not going to occur in the 21st century! Instead global average temperatures will continue to increase.
Environment - David Karoly - 35 comments
 
It seems that Kevin Rudd's Government has given China a broad degree of latitude outside normal diplomatic behaviour.
International - Peter Coates - 36 comments
 
We need to reshape the way humanity produces food, feeds itself and manages Earth's natural resources.
Environment - Julian Cribb - 23 comments
 
In Jane Austen's novels God is displaced by aesthetics and manners and fine sentiment.
Religion & Spirituality - Peter Sellick - 25 comments
 
The tax hike on pre-mixed drinks will yield $500 million for the next four years. That's a lot of money for a government with election promises to keep.
Society - Jeremy Sammut - 7 comments
 
Providing the appropriate legal underpinning to future relations would be a significant step for Indigenous Australians.
Indigenous Affairs - Megan Davis and Sarah Maddison - 8 comments
 

Friday, May 2, 2008

Academic freedom, religious freedom and gay rights: why 'questioning the secular' is a reactionary discourse.
Religion & Spirituality - Bronwyn Winter - 60 comments
 
The reason for China's intransigence on Tibet is simple - it intends to divert the Brahmaputra River, devastating flows to India and Bangladesh.
International - Arthur Thomas - 22 comments
 
Domestic violence policy is overwhelmingly dominated by the idea that it is something that men do to women.
Society - Roger Smith - 65 comments
 
The Indian 20-20 cricket scene is surely unprecedented in the annals of this rather stuffy sport. We might as well be in Yankee stadium!
Sport - Binoy Kampmark - 5 comments
 
During the next few weeks expect a speech from Obama where he defends his patriotism and his connections with the common folk.
International - Brendon O'Connor - 2 comments
 
It is unfortunate that public school teachers get continual sniping from certain educational commentators.
Education - Ian Keese - 15 comments
 

Thursday, May 1, 2008

May Day is a day to celebrate international working class solidarity. It stands for better wages, working and living conditions.
Society - John Passant - 15 comments
 
To negative gear and minimise stamp duty, buy the home you want to invest in and rent the one you live in.
Economics - Gavin Putland
 
The ideas for education coming out of the Summit were a bit underwhelming.
Education - Chris Bonnor - 12 comments
 
I wish I could be a more enthusiastic summiteer, but putting 1,000 'brainy' people into workshops produced very little.
Domestic Politics - Lyn Allison - 11 comments
 
It is an indictment on successive governments that Australia remains one of only two OECD countries without paid maternity leave.
Society - Natasha Stott Despoja - 39 comments
 
'You'll regret it if you don't wear white.' Weddings aren’t really about the people getting married as much as what they mean to the people around them.
Society - Louisa Davin - 10 comments
 

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

It is the right of all citizens to have access to a life sustaining supply of potable water so how will trading in water and water licences achieve this?
Political Philosophy - Bruce Haigh - 10 comments
 
Are we adopting American spelling because it is somehow superior? Are we happy with this? Do we care?
Society - Louise Schaper - 18 comments
 
It is difficult to avoid the conclusion that the Rudd Government's proposals far from constitute an education 'revolution'.
Education - Des Moore - 6 comments
 
The prices of food, oil, petrol and money are all going up. What is going on?
Economics - Peter Jonson - 2 comments
 
It is possible for householders to work out how to dispose of their rubbish without using so many plastic bags.
Environment - Valerie Yule - 12 comments
 
Australian public policy, and our economy, could benefit from the use of randomised trials to evaluate them first.
April Feature - Andrew Leigh - 1 comment
 
Enhancing the Australian mortgage-backed securities market to lower mortgage costs.
Economics - Greg Medcraft - 3 comments
 

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

The odds are at least 50-50 that we will see significant cooling rather than warming in coming decades.
Environment - Phil Chapman - 17 comments
 
Britain - the Falkland Isles - and Argentina are both likely to bid for an expansion to their country's territory - and it's all about oil.
International - John Lea
 
The ultimate consumer is consumerism itself, and the things it consumes are us.
Society - Malcolm King - 5 comments
 
More die each year in workplaces than in the conflicts that plague their nations. They die quietly and with no fanfare.
International - Melody Kemp - 9 comments
 
Spirituality is a burgeoning industry, but is it good for mental health?
Religion & Spirituality - Rosemary Aird - 16 comments
 
It seems important to ask whether our forbearers fought for a just cause, or at least, a well justified cause.
Society - Brendon O'Connor - 50 comments
 

Monday, April 28, 2008

The great historical issues of our day are being decided not by historical argument, but by parliamentary vote, with judges enforcing these decisions.
Law & Liberties - Paul Doolan - 31 comments
 
Producers toy with scarcity, allowing fuel prices to soar, while the earth edges closer to catastrophe.
Environment - James Hansen - 24 comments
 
To fight climate change environmental necessity must trump political convenience.
Environment - Bo Ekman - 7 comments
 
Is it possible that coal corporations know that carbon capture and storage is not viable, but continue to promote it to maintain share prices?
Environment - Tony Troughton-Smith - 18 comments
 
Many Australians erroneously assume the Constitution protects fundamental rights and freedoms.
Law & Liberties - Graeme Innes - 14 comments
 
In the short term, it’s unlikely that the US will be able to challenge China’s status as the official Olympic champion of executions.
Law & Liberties - Jeff Sparrow - 5 comments
 

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Anzac day is a day of delusion: we have created a day of celebration of nationhood when we need a day of recognition that war is nothing but the ultimate human failure.
Science & Technology - Brian Holden - 135 comments
 
A HREOC Background Paper provides an international context to examine the Federal Racial Discrimination Act
Law & Liberties - Tom Calma - 8 comments
 
A new world is emerging that will require the recycling of waste that has not previously been recycled. And it is happening in China.
Environment - David DuByne - 3 comments
 
The central reason the republic referendum went down in 1999 is that the people could not accept the model being foisted upon them. The people wanted the power to appoint the head of state.
Political Philosophy - Nick Ferrett - 25 comments
 
For historians, Anzac Day, is 'a martial affair with military music and ritual', while for churches and their army chaplains, it’s a 'faith event'.
Society - Alan Matheson - 10 comments
 
Climate change: focusing on economics alone is to suggest that the market can sort it all out. But clearly it hasn't, can't and won't.
Environment - Simon Roz - 8 comments
 

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

How can we now get the public to take seriously peak oil concerns when these have not been rubber-stamped as 'valid' by Rudd’s Summit?
Environment - Michael Lardelli - 24 comments
 
At Kevin Rudd's 2020 Summit many nuggety little ideas emerged; not just in the official documents, but in conversations between participants.
Domestic Politics - Andrew Leigh - 10 comments
 
The 2020 Summit has lifted a cloud, providing 'permission' for Australians to reassess their own lives and where we are heading as a nation.
Society - Ken Boundy - 5 comments
 
If ever there was a measure as to how far above its weight Australia punches on the world stage, it’s our vast, diverse, talented community of expats.
Society - Bryan Gaensler - 6 comments
 
Kevin Rudd returned from overseas to be faced with the circus of the 2020 Summit and a raft of under performing Ministers.
Domestic Politics - Bruce Haigh - 6 comments
 
The first Anzac Day was an attempt to divert anger away from the capitalist class using the false idea of nationhood.
Political Philosophy - John Passant - 32 comments
 

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Alan Trounson's 'Frodo moment': embryonic stem cell research looks like becoming obsolete and women decline to donate their eggs.
Health - Michael Cook - 8 comments
 
Comparing the US sub-prime crisis to the great depression, or the 1970's oil crisis, is simply overblown.
Economics - Sinclair Davidson - 12 comments
 
If the Doha round stalls again we will see if Rudd’s free trade ideals are just rhetoric or reality.
Economics - Clarissa Keil
 
Due to the Bush administration's policy blunders, Iraq has now become an Iranian issue as well.
International - Dilip Hiro - 5 comments
 
If a republican model is to be put to the Australian people, as the 2020 Summit proposes, then it must be one that emerges from a community process.
Political Philosophy - Greg Barns and Anna Krawec-Wheaton - 15 comments
 
Geography is an essential tool in determining the future direction of the Australian economy.
April Feature - Brad Ruting - 6 comments
 

Monday, April 21, 2008

Schools today treat students as clients, to be taught the same material, at the same pace, at the same age, in the same manner.
Education - John Daicopoulos - 17 comments
 
Rewarding farmers for more sustainable practices will allow our children to enjoy their desserts without expanding our deserts.
Environment - Jim Scott - 8 comments
 
Many studies demonstrate the savings to society from investment in those who are disadvantaged.
Society - Rob Salter - 5 comments
 
Senator Clinton needs to win the Pennsylvania primary not just by a little, but by a wide margin, to re-establish her credibility and to re-energise her supporters.
International - Walt Brasch - 1 comment
 
Australia is now a nation of dual-breadwinner households, although women continue to be the second or marginal income earner.
April Feature - Angela Barns and Alison Preston - 26 comments
 
To achieve better educational outcomes for Indigenous Australians we need to give tangible evidence that we value their cultures as much as we value our own.
Indigenous Affairs - Jan Ferguson - 19 comments
 

Friday, April 18, 2008

In China when the Games are over, industry will ratchet up production, pollution will worsen, the media will be muzzled and 11 new cities will be built around Beijing ...
International - Arthur Thomas - 36 comments
 
Rather than waging history wars about the honour of the victors, perhaps we ought to try to understand the experience of those who were conquered and suffered.
Society - Dirk Moses - 19 comments
 
Do Muslim women wear the veil out of their own free will or are they forced to wear it?
Political Philosophy - Kees Bakhuyzen - 107 comments
 
As the countdown to the 2020 Summit continues, participants have been getting in early with their favourite ideas.
Domestic Politics - Henry Thornton - 9 comments
 
Those opposed to a republic are using tired arguments against the renewed debate. Their arguments are at odds with the spirit of 2020.
Law & Liberties - John Warhurst - 18 comments
 
As anyone who has tried to call an electrician or plumber knows, we have an overheated economy, bumping up against supply constraints.
April Feature - Ian McAuley - 6 comments
 

Thursday, April 17, 2008

The argument is if human activity has added to the current, natural warming cycle: and if it hasn't then why spend up big on carbon trading?
Environment - Mark S. Lawson - 66 comments
 
Friedrich Hayek theorised, quite rightly, that central planning is a dysfunctional way to run an economy.
April Feature - Nicholas Gruen - 6 comments
 
Big house, big car, big TV, big mortgage? And you can't make ends meet?
Society - Steven French - 26 comments
 
Achieving an Indigenous treaty in Australia would be a long, hard process but it could help bridge the gulf between Indigenous people and the rest of Australia.
Indigenous Affairs - George Williams - 6 comments
 
Indigenous parents should not have to wait to experience tangible improvements in their children’s education.
Indigenous Affairs - Brendan Darcy
 
Persistent questions in our media about the US's readiness for a black or female president ignore some interesting facts.
International - Ben-Peter Terpstra - 3 comments
 

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Freedom of opinion and expression. How important are they as values to those of us in western, democratic societies?
Law & Liberties - Alamgir Hussain - 40 comments
 
The 2020 Summit is a chance to switch the focus of public debate from complaints about our system of government to ideas on how to improve it.
Law & Liberties - Anne Twomey - 6 comments
 
Our GPs are vanishing from inner cities and rural areas placing an undue burden on hospital emergency departments.
Health - Barbara Reynolds-Hutchinson - 7 comments
 
Book review: 'Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA', by Tim Weiner, reveals a failing and deficient CIA.
International - Reg Little - 1 comment
 
Nation's future health goes on life support. Think prevention - not just cure: this is how Australia must fight emerging epidemics.
Health - Todd Harper - 7 comments
 
The 2020 Summit could well present that critical podium Indigenous people have been seeking for so long.
Indigenous Affairs - Stephen Hagan - 7 comments
 

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

How can Pakistani politicians, who have not earned a single day’s bread in their lifetime, fathom and solve the real issues for ordinary Pakistanis?
International - Aslam Naru - 3 comments
 
The Olympics is invariably tainted. Far from being an occasion for uplift, the games invariably provide a time for mourning.
Sport - Binoy Kampmark - 13 comments
 
Kevin Rudd needs to know that Australia has a big repair job to do at the UN.
Domestic Politics - Tony Kevin - 25 comments
 
The Jewish establishment fails to understand the shifting sands of the debate.
International - Antony Loewenstein - 97 comments
 
A wonderful life - a tribute to Lionel Hogg who passed away in February 2008. He was the inspiration for his son, Lionel Hogg, co-founder with Graham Young of 'On Line Opinion'.
Society - Lionel Hogg - 4 comments
 
Many in society do not value the disabled and equally do not value the disability support workers who help them achieve.
Health - Peter Gibilisco and Debbie Mackenzie - 3 comments
 

Monday, April 14, 2008

When partial compliance is as bad as none: the Paradise Dam in Queensland has a fishway for the Australian Lungfish that is all but useless.
Environment - Roger Currie - 3 comments
 
Why, as a shrewd politician, did John Howard not ratify the Kyoto Protocol?
Domestic Politics - Jenny Stewart - 14 comments
 
The question is how many of those attending Kevin Rudd's 2020 Summit will be able to afford to disagree with the Government?
Domestic Politics - John Roskam - 17 comments
 
There is a political-corporate-union-business alliance in Tasmania that has given Gunns the green light for its pulp mill.
Political Philosophy - Peter Henning - 9 comments
 
Technology has resulted in teenagers and young adults having a very different conception of privacy.
Society - Peter Black - 2 comments
 
The federal government is looking at filtering content at the Internet Service Provider (ISP) level, but it doesn't work.
Science & Technology - Chris Abood - 1 comment
 

Advertisement
About Us Search Discuss Feedback Legals Privacy