Like what you've read?

On Line Opinion is the only Australian site where you get all sides of the story. We don't
charge, but we need your support. Here�s how you can help.

  • Advertise

    We have a monthly audience of 70,000 and advertising packages from $200 a month.

  • Volunteer

    We always need commissioning editors and sub-editors.

  • Contribute

    Got something to say? Submit an essay.


 The National Forum   Donate   Your Account   On Line Opinion   Forum   Blogs   Polling   About   
On Line Opinion logo ON LINE OPINION - Australia's e-journal of social and political debate

Subscribe!
Subscribe





On Line Opinion is a not-for-profit publication and relies on the generosity of its sponsors, editors and contributors. If you would like to help, contact us.
___________

Syndicate
RSS/XML


RSS 2.0

SpongeBob comes a Buster with US Christian Right

By Jane Rankin-Reid - posted Tuesday, 8 March 2005


It’s pay back time in the afternoon wastelands of American TV. By mid-January, during one of democracy’s raciest first weeks in office, the Bush Administration’s newest faces swiftly began to stake their claim on US children’s televisual headspaces. Bush’s newly appointed Education Secretary, Margaret Spellings, had spent exactly two days in her office before threatening PBS, the nation’s only non-profit broadcast network with funding cuts if it aired a contentious six-minute episode from Post Cards From Buster, a program aimed at three to seven year olds.

In the “Sugartime” segment, the asthmatic, animated, video-camera toting rabbit Buster visits a family in Vermont to learn about making maple syrup. According to PBS’s Kids Online site Buster is a curious youngster raised by divorced parents who “models the language young English learners need in order to find their way around, make new friends, learn more about other people's lives, interests, and cultures, and share information about themselves”.

Previously, Buster has visited Muslims, Mormons, Orthodox Jews and Pentecostal Christians. And although his “Sugartime” report on modern farming does not include any references to the sexual orientation of his host family of two lesbian mums and their respective kids, nonetheless Spellings’ spelled out her objections to Buster’s covert de-sensitising of US kids about same sex families. “Many parents would not want their young children exposed to the lifestyles portrayed in this episode”, Spellings wrote in her letter to Pat Mitchell, CEO of PBS.

Advertisement

Unsurprisingly, PBS pulled “Sugartime” from its 350 plus stations’ national program schedule although Buster’s producers WGBH Boston - funded by Congress’ Ready To Learn Program - later made the show available to up to 20 station affiliates. When questioned about the changes a PBS spokesperson admitted cautiously, “The debate surrounding this might cause parents to be concerned about PBS as a safe harbour”.

Only a fortnight earlier the controversy was preceded by the latest misadventures of SpongeBob SquarePants. Although American children have survived decades of Disney’s unemployed non-denominational mice, rabbits, cats, coyotes, beagles and other mixed breed canines all beating each other to smithereens in front of their young eyes, not to mention the long standing cross species love interest between Kermit the Frog and Miss Piggy, the Christian Right want to shelter this generation of children from the creep of contemporary, cartoon-driven ideologies.

The anti-cartoon campaign is symptomatic of further blistering tensions in US society as the fundamentalist agenda gains traction in the American schoolroom. Under intense pressure the study of evolution has all but disappeared from children’s learning experiences. These days many teachers are so scared of raising the issue, that while evolution is still published in school textbooks, it’s rarely taught out loud in the American classroom.

So perhaps it’s unsurprising that SpongeBob SquarePants would also emerge on US Christian Right’s moral offense radar. Last summer, in cities from Portland to Newark, gay and straight Americans with time on their hands and humour to burn, defiantly reconfigured SpongeBob’s plot line in response to their personal identification with his lifestyle. Now SpongeBob’s in a tsumani load of trouble, for his unwitting double life as a part-time gay icon after being spotted on screen holding hands with a starfish!

That’s right, Patrick, a modest unemployed five limbed marine creature dressed in a pair of loud floral board-shorts, could be engaged in an unconventional “friendship” with a mouthy block of foam! His creators at Nickelodeon claim the cartoon is totally asexual. But according to pro-family conservatives, drawing his flag wedged between Patrick’s buttocks in one of the duo’s many escapes from demonic fast food forces, not to mention their drunken stupor after too many ice cream sundaes at The Goofy Goober in SpongeBob SquarePants The Movie, is proof he’s hell bent on brainwashing kids.

He’s dangerous according to Forum of the Family’s spiritual leader the Reverend James Dodson who believes SpongeBob’s biggest sin is endorsing a “tolerance pledge” on the We Are Family Foundation’s website.The pledge button links to the www.tolerance.org site containing references to offensive “lifestyles” which should immediately be removed, according to Forum for the Family spokespeople.

Advertisement

Until recently, the WAF Foundation’s kid orientated tolerance booster was considered a healthy contribution to First Lady Laura Bush’s No Child Left Behind nationwide educational initiative. To celebrate a National “We Are Family” Day on March 6, the WAF Foundation has released an educational video cartoon featuring 100 of the world’s best-loved animated identities singing the hit song in rousing harmonies. Joining SpongeBob in We Are Family’s high profile choral line- up are Big Bird, Lionel and Leona from Between the Lions, Clifford the Big Red Dog, Barney the Dinosaur, Pooh Bear, Madeline, Dora the Explorer, Jimmy Neutron, Rugrats, Lilo and Stitch, the Muppets and other well known Sesame Street stars.

Mark Barondess, lawyer for the WAF Foundation told US media that anyone who sees harm in the benign video’s child friendly content “needs medication”.

Indeed the We Are Family DVD, distributed throughout 61,000 US primary schools by co-sponsor Federal Express, is a unique event, according to producers who spent three long years organising dozens of cartoon’s busy schedules for the recording sessions. “Co-operation and unity are among the most important things we can teach children”, says WAF Foundation’s founder, pop hit songwriter Nile Rodgers possibly reflecting on his experience of rounding up the wicked drawings.

So why did the Christian Right single out SpongeBob for censor? The AFA believes its plot line is “an insidious means by which the organisation is manipulating and potentially brainwashing kids. It’s a classic bait and switch". To date, Madeline, Big Bird, Dora and Pooh have escaped moral condemnation for associating with SpongeBob.

Faced with widespread ridicule, Dodson was quick to highlight the hellish media plot which had swiftly built against him, urging his followers to redirect their fury towards the eight page teachers’ guide accompanying the DVD. The We Are Family Foundation’s Teachers Guide references same-sex parents and suggests how teachers might respond if kids ask about non-typical familial assemblages, such as adoptive parents and stepsiblings. Heavens above! All this life shaping undercover content squeezed into a hundred afternoon TV identities, including a talking sponge who’s hung-on to his day job! “Tolerance itself can be a dangerous word”, the Reverend Terry Fox, a southern Baptist pastor from Wichita Kansas said. “Tolerance gives the public schools an avenue to literally brainwash our kids that every lifestyle is OK.”

When questioned about the SpongeBob-Buster controversy later on C-Span, President Bush told America, “They put an ‘off’ button on the TV for a reason. Turn it off”.

In truth the story has impacted acutely on contemporary American public debate. NBC’s Keith Olberman, hosting the network’s popular Bloggerman website was torpedoed with volumes of unpleasant mail from Conservative Christians, often generated directly from Reverend Dobson’s website exhorting true believers to help force American media to stop “distorting” his words. Olberman was surprised at the percentage of emails expressing anger at the lack of an even more virulent “anti-homosexual agenda”. Others sound even more rabid if that’s possible: “I showed respect even though I disagreed with you and yet you have the audacity to call me intelligent.” A significant quantity evoked threats of “what we did to Dan Rather” (who’d retired some months ago after a long career on CBS Evening News) and “we got Tom Brokaw at ABC and we can get you”. Many of the emails Olberman received were generated from Reverend Dodson’s website to force American media to stop “distorting” his words.

Unsurprisingly, the SpongeBob and Buster stories have persisted in newspapers, TV and radio in isolated cities and towns throughout the US, Canada, UK and now here in Australia. Regional commentators have used the story to point out the hypocrisies of Secretary Spellings and Reverend Dobson’s intolerant views on the acceptability of homosexuality in our communities, so that their specious bigotry can be openly countenanced. The Bush Administration’s increased vulnerability to Christian conservatives' self-described “spiritual battle for America’s soul” is not something leading liberal commentators believe US society can afford to ignore if America is to retain its democratic integrity. Weeks ago, Doug Ireland’s LA Weekly column Post Cards of Intolerance raised the alarm of the dangers of self-censorship emerging from within the liberal left.

Ireland interviewed Harvard University’s Arthur Lipton who noted, “when PBS engage(s) in this sort of self censorship, it sets a very poor example for teachers, who get little encouragement to teach tolerance in schools - they’ll say, if these so called good liberals won’t stand up, why should I risk getting in trouble or losing my job by teaching tolerance of gay people”.

If anything though, the New York Times’  Frank Rich is even angrier at the Administration’s pandering to the Christian right wing. Last month he wrote, “Inane though it may be that Ms. Spellings is conducting a witch hunt against Buster or that James Dobson has taken aim at SpongBob SquarePants, there’s a method in their idiocy: the cartoon surrogates are deliberately chosen to camouflage the harshness of their assault on nonanimated, flesh and blood people.”

Last week’s Oscar Awards Ceremony ABC broadcast was to have included comedian Robin William’s satirical quips about the Reverend Dodson’s SpongeBob escapades. Fearing fundamentalist reprisals, the network pulled William’s best lines at the last minute. In response, the comic went on stage wearing white tape plastered symbolically over his mouth, pained that his biggest laughs had been so brutally culled now that Bush’s “faith based” agenda has taken such firm hold of America’s sense of humor.

In spite of all this, Education Secretary Margaret Spellings is adamant that rather than increasing funding to under resourced, over-crowded US primary schools, the nation’s parents can now choose what educational content their children receive. It is a recipe for generational mayhem that shortchanges children basic social survival skills. Imagine if your kids realise you’ve opted them out of the tough tolerance and diversity subjects at school, in favor of safe fundamentally sanctioned topics, because their teachers are too scared to teach from the modern curriculum and you’re afraid to rock the boat in your community? Expect a mass outbreak of class actions conducted by angry young intolerant adults who show up holding hands with a starfish to slap a lawsuit on you for intellectual manipulation and ideological oppression.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. All


Discuss in our Forums

See what other readers are saying about this article!

Click here to read & post comments.

81 posts so far.

Share this:
reddit this reddit thisbookmark with del.icio.us Del.icio.usdigg thisseed newsvineSeed NewsvineStumbleUpon StumbleUponsubmit to propellerkwoff it

About the Author

Jane Rankin-Reid is a former Mercury Sunday Tasmanian columnist, now a Principal Correspondent at Tehelka, India. Her most recent public appearance was with the Hobart Shouting Choir roaring the Australian national anthem at the Hobart Comedy Festival's gala evening at the Theatre Royal.

Other articles by this Author

All articles by Jane Rankin-Reid
Related Links
Buster Home Page
SpongeBob SquarePants Home Page

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Photo of Jane Rankin-Reid
Article Tools
Comment 81 comments
Print Printable version
Subscribe Subscribe
Email Email a friend
Advertisement

About Us Search Discuss Feedback Legals Privacy