Like what you've read?

On Line Opinion is the only Australian site where you get all sides of the story. We don't
charge, but we need your support. Here�s how you can help.

  • Advertise

    We have a monthly audience of 70,000 and advertising packages from $200 a month.

  • Volunteer

    We always need commissioning editors and sub-editors.

  • Contribute

    Got something to say? Submit an essay.


 The National Forum   Donate   Your Account   On Line Opinion   Forum   Blogs   Polling   About   
On Line Opinion logo ON LINE OPINION - Australia's e-journal of social and political debate

Subscribe!
Subscribe





On Line Opinion is a not-for-profit publication and relies on the generosity of its sponsors, editors and contributors. If you would like to help, contact us.
___________

Syndicate
RSS/XML


RSS 2.0

Female MPs in NSW – a plateau at best

By Tony Smith - posted Thursday, 24 March 2011


Australian elections emphasise competition between alternative governments and premiers. Local government elections are exceptions but federal and state campaigns are highly centralised around leaders and dominated by major parties hoping to form government. Campaigns should perform many functions such as allowing expression of public will around issues, rejuvenation of democracy and securing representation. In New South Wales next Saturday, 494 candidates will contest 93 separate lower house electorates. For various reasons however, the media reduces the choice to that between Labor Premier Kristina Keneally, a candidate in the seat of Heffron, and Liberal Leader Barry O’Farrell, running in Ku-ring-gai.

Concentration of interest is understandable because when members of the Legislative Assembly return to Parliament, they choose a premier and government from their number. Curiously however, while there is wide interest in the partisan composition of the parliament after 26th March, other aspects of the parliament’s aggregate membership receive scant pre-poll attention. There has been little comment about the extent to which parliament will reflect the state’s diverse population in age, gender or ethnicity. While individual MPs will provide excellent representation for constituents, collectively parliament’s image might seem to be dominated by elites.

It is widely believed among both politicians and the general public that more broadly representative assemblies make better decisions. In relation to gender it is accepted that ideally, males and females should be present roughly in proportion to their presence in the population. For reasons of equal opportunity and improved legislation, about half of our MPs should be women. But while this principle is widely approved, there is no consensus about how this balance should be achieved. Suggestions include electoral reform and introduction of quotas within parties. Some observers expect incremental progress parallel with women’s rising social and economic status.

Advertisement

Female MPs generally acknowledge that their predecessors made it easier for them. As more women are elected and become role models, women will be seen as normal MPs and so their numbers will increase. After critical mass is reached growth will be self-generating. Yet despite the obvious abilities of current female MPs, women’s numbers are unlikely to grow after 26th March. At the 2010 federal election, women’s numbers in the House of Representatives fell from 41 to 37. The state election imminent in NSW could well see women’s numbers reach a plateau there too.

The Legislative Council

Antony Green’s peerless election guide (www.abc.net.au/elections/nsw/2011) shows every candidate for the 93 Legislative Assembly electorates and the lists for the return of half the Legislative Council (21 members). Over recent decades the Council has had a higher proportion of female members than the Assembly. About one in three MLCs have been female, with 13 of 42 currently. Since 1995, when just 15% of MLAs were female, women’s numbers in that chamber grew to over 25% at the 1999 election.

Unfortunately, there are poor prospects for the return of female MLCs after 26th March. Unless five females are returned among the 21 newly elected MLCs, their numbers will fall. That seems a modest demand, but many advocates of female representation believe that women are actually favoured by the upper house electoral system, proportional representation (PR). A more realistic view, if perhaps a cynical one is that it is not PR systems as such that favour women candidates but the attitudes of party preselectors. Older major parties (Labor and the Liberal and National Coalition partners) regard upper house seats as career backwaters not coveted by ambitious men. Newer parties such as the Greens and the once influential Democrats are advantaged (relative to single member constituencies) by PR systems. These parties, which formed in the modern era, are less prejudiced against women’s public roles.

The candidate lists are instructive. There are so many candidates (311) that the ballot paper is known colloquially as ‘the tablecloth’. Voters can cast their ballots by numbering (at least 15) squares next to individual candidates, names ‘below the line’ or by endorsing ‘group’ tickets ‘above the line’ (at least one). As the vast majority of voters opt for the simpler solution of voting for groups, the order of candidates on the group (usually ‘party’) lists is vital. In a polarised campaign, it is possible that the major parties could share the 21 seats. In recent times however, about a third of MLCs have sat on the ‘crossbenches’. This has reflected the statewide vote. Assembly elections however, return predominantly major party candidates and a sprinkling of Independents but no minor party candidates, although their vote in the lower chamber is often just as strong as in the Council.

Among 16 groups competing for Council seats in 2011, only one is headed by a woman, Pauline Hanson. The Coalition ticket, which opinion polls suggest is likely to be strong, has men in the first six positions. Labor has women at positions three and seven. Of the minor parties, only the Greens and the Christian Democrats are running candidates in most electorates in the lower house and so they are the most likely to succeed in the Council. The Greens have female candidates at two and four. The Christian Democrats have a woman at number five. These are the parties most generous towards female candidates.

The Legislative Assembly

The gender balance amongst Assembly candidates is better but hardly approaches 50:50. Of 494 candidates, 148 (about 30%) are women. If one-third of successful candidates were women, then this would mean the election of 31 women, which would seem like progress. Such aggregates can be deceptive however because many candidates – male and female - are ‘flag-wavers’ for parties with no hope of election. They gain experience and party gratitude and help to boost the vote in the Council. They might hope to influence outcomes by advising followers how to distribute preferences, but their chances are slim.

Advertisement

Ideally, gender politics should not be just about women MPs. Ignoring males means that they escape critical scrutiny and suggests that they do not have and use gender politically. Continual concentration on women tends to make it seem as though they are the problem. On the other hand, observers who are interested in gender are usually advocates of a better balanced parliament, and as there are fewer women candidates, an examination of their fortunes in an election is simpler. As parliament is comprised of males and females, ratios can be reversed to focus on male success rates.

Prior to the 2011 election there were 24 females in the 93 seat Assembly (16 Labor members, five Liberal, two Independents and one National Party MP). Labor has had more female members than other parties in recent parliaments, currently two-thirds. The numbers of females returned in 2011 will almost certainly reflect the relative fortunes of the parties and it is no secret that Labor is expected to lose many seats. Antony Green’s ‘Calculator’ based on swings predicted in recent Newspoll surveys of opinions and voting intentions suggests that Labor could be reduced to about 18 seats. Women currently constitute about a third of Labor’s MLAs and it will be interesting to see whether that fraction grows or falls post-election.

Among 93 electorates, eight have no female candidate and must return a male MP. Every electorate has at least one male candidate. Many other electorates (48) have no major party female. Two of these, Sydney and Dubbo, have sitting female Independents, but even omitting these (and so 46) brings the total of seats that must have male MPs to 54.

There are no major party male candidates in contention in eleven seats, so these will most certainly return female MPs. These seats are Blue Mountains, Burrinjuck, Goulburn, Heffron, Kogarah, Marrickville, Mulgoa, North Shore, Shellharbour, Vaucluse and Wollongong. The Coalition holds four and Labor seven. But of those seven held by Labor, Blue Mountains, Mulgoa and Marrickville and possibly (though unlikely) Kogarah could change party. Marrickville could go Green and the others Liberal. The Wollongong newspaper Illawarra Mercury (19-20th March) revealed the results of a survey that suggested a male Independent could challenge the Labor MP Noreen Hay, but she has a margin of some 25%. The Independent Clover Moore seems safe in the seat of Sydney, but Dawn Fardell could lose Dubbo. It will depend on whether the anti-Labor sentiment translates into a pro-Coalition swing. So, it seems likely that women will hold these 12 seats.

In addition, female candidates should hold some safe seats against male challengers. Liberal women will hold Willoughby and South Coast, bringing the female total to 14. Labor’s female candidates should hold four seats with huge margins in Auburn, Bankstown, Canterbury, and Wallsend, bringing the total to 18. With a margin of 15.1%, Cabinet Minister Victoria Judge should hold Strathfield but could suffer because of media criticisms. One argument about women MPs has been that they behave with integrity. Unfortunately, as women have come closer to power, lapses become more likely. A by-election was necessary in Penrith after the removal of its Labor MP and Labor disendorsed the Member for Drummoyne following an adverse report on her conduct. Newspapers have repeated allegations accusing both Premier Kristina Keneally and Judge of conflicts of interest. Strathfield is a volatile seat and Judge is by no means assured of victory, although she must be favoured in a tight contest. Indeed, unfounded allegations could backfire against Judge’s political opponents. So, Labor’s five safe seats should bring the total to 19.

Other wins by female candidates are a matter for speculation. The 1996 federal election saw a huge influx of female Liberal ‘freshers’. Labor women, supporting their own party’s commitment to specific aims and quotas, tended to dismiss these Liberal female MPs as the accidental result of a landslide and predicted that they would be one-termers. In the landslide expected in NSW this time, several Coalition women could seize seats. Liberals Robyn Parker in Maitland (swing required 9.7) and Melanie Gibbons in Menai (2.7) are likely winners. Nationals Leslie Williams in Port Macquarie (4.5) and Alison Davey in Cessnock (12.4) also have good chances. Liberal Kirsty Lloyd has an outside chance in Toongabbie (14.5) against former Premier Nathan Rees.

It is a matter of history that female members of the federal Liberal ‘Class of 1996’ saved the Howard Government from defeat in 1998. As strong, hard working local members, several MPs in outer Sydney withstood the general anti-government swing. The same could happen this time with Labor women. Verity Firth could hold on in Balmain (3.7) and Jodie McKay in Newcastle (1.2). It is possible, if unlikely that new candidates Katie Smith (Gosford 4.9) and Therese Cook (Miranda 0.8) could hold against the swing expected by male challengers. Labor has only one female candidate challenging for a marginal seat. While it seems improbable, new candidate Kate Washington might defy the swing and retake Port Stephens (0.1) and Independent Dawn Fardell could retain Dubbo (0.9).

Of interest to the final party balance among female MPs are four seats with females assured of victory. In Kogarah, Cherie Burton’s margin of 17.7 should be enough against Liberal challenger Miray Hindi. In Mulgoa and Blue Mountains, new Labor candidates Prue Guillaume and Trish Doyle each have margins of 11.1 against Liberal challengers Tanya Davies and Rosa Sage respectively. In Marrickville Deputy Premier Carmel Tebbutt has a margin of 7.5 with the main challenge from the Greens’ Fiona Byrne.

Prospects for female candidates 2011 election Legislative Assembly

Seats (19) likely to return female MLAs

Other

Labor

Coalition (Liberal)

Sydney

Heffron

Shellharbour

Wollongong

Auburn

Bankstown

Canterbury

Wallsend

Kogarah

Strathfield

---------------------------

Mulgoa (or Liberal)

Blue Mountains (or Liberal)

Marrickville (or Green)

Burrinjuck (NP)

Willoughby Goulburn

Vaucluse

North Shore

South Coast

 

Seats (11) that might return female MLAs possible, most likely at top

 

 

 

 

--------------------------

 

Dubbo

 

 

 

 

---------------------------

Gosford

Balmain

Newcastle

Miranda

Port Stephens

Menai

Port Macquarie

Maitland

Cessnock

--------------------------

 

 

Toongabbie

 

Twenty-six female candidates were successful in 2007 and 24 were members of the Assembly in late 2010. At the 2011 election, those numbers are unlikely to increase.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. All


Discuss in our Forums

See what other readers are saying about this article!

Click here to read & post comments.

5 posts so far.

Share this:
reddit this reddit thisbookmark with del.icio.us Del.icio.usdigg thisseed newsvineSeed NewsvineStumbleUpon StumbleUponsubmit to propellerkwoff it

About the Author

Dr Tony Smith is a writer living in country New South Wales. He holds a PhD in political science and has had articles and reviews published in various newspapers, periodicals and journals. He contributed a poem 'Evil equations' to an anthology of anti-war poems delivered to the Prime Minister on the eve of war.

Other articles by this Author

All articles by Tony Smith

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Photo of Tony Smith
Article Tools
Comment 5 comments
Print Printable version
Subscribe Subscribe
Email Email a friend
Advertisement

About Us Search Discuss Feedback Legals Privacy